Just Fine, A Little Too, and Not Enough
Despite the implication in the e-mail I described yesterday, it turns out I can wear whatever I want to my company's annual dinner. So I think I will.
War and Remembrance is a "what-might-have-been" collection. Back in the early 80s, writer Roger Stern and artist John Byrne teamed up to produce nine solid issues of Marvel's patriotic Avenger. The stories are all quite good, including the single issue in which Cap considers making a bid for the US Presidency, but there's a sense that they were merely gearing up for a good, long run with some very weighty stories along the way, as several germs of long-term plot threads are introduced (including Bernie Rosenthal, who would become Cap's love interest under another writer before being unceremoniously written out by a third writer).
Roger Stern is one of comic books' greatest unsung talents, probably because he mostly applies himself to superhero yarns. But he always has solid plots with outstanding characterization, treating his figures as real people, not archetypes. If he has a weakness, it's that his villains are often one-dimensional, but it's not enough to really hurt his stories. For my money, his best work was his mid-80s run on Doctor Strange.
Operation: Rebirth was published towards the end of Cap's first series, only two or three years ago. It involves picking up the pieces left after the rather messy final plot under writer Mark Gruenwald came to an end. (Gruenwald is another solid writer, but he definitely outstayed his welcome on Cap.) Writer Mark Waid and penciller Ron Garney bring a certain grittiness to Cap's adventures, which they're continuing in his current series which started just a few months ago. Waid has done better work, and his and Garney's rendition of Cap makes him seem a little too aloof, intense, and even downright nasty. It's decent stuff, worth reading, but I'd like them to loosen up a little bit.
Can we reasonably infer from the episode's final scene that Sheridan and Lochley are former lovers? While it could spice things up among some of the rather goody-goody characters, it does seem like a kind of lame contrivance, don't you think?