Cerebus
Home Comic Books
Last updated: 10 August 1997
Cerebus #196, by Dave Sim, Aardvark-Vanaheim
"Mothers And Daughters" continues to limp towards its conclusion, having been, so far, even more boring (albeit far more inflammatory) than "Church And State".

The art is still lovely, but Dave Sim's aardvark protagonist and other characters seem to become less likable all the time, and at this point it seems painfully obvious that Sim is ad-libbing a lot of this stuff as he goes along. While his material always reflects a lot of deep thought, the story has become a lot thinner since Sim entered his preaching mode earlier in "M&D".

I remember once reading Sim stating that he could think of few more worthy ends for his artistic career than to chronicle the totality of a single character's life. Given that much of the past hundred issues have not dealt much with Cerebus himself, and given that Cerebus seems to have changed very little during that span (despite the promising implications of "Melmoth"), I find myself wondering exactly what it is about his goal that interested him. Or maybe he's just given it up.

Reviewed September 1995


Update: "Mothers and Daughters" fizzled out with #200, and Cerebus then launched a "short story" entitled "Guys". Sim's storytelling sense seems to have headed south altogether; he's far more interested in Making a Point than in telling a good story, in my judgment. I gave up on Cerebus with #208. A sad commentary on a series which published one of the single best stories in comics history, in "Jaka's Story". Oh, well.


hits since 24 August 2000.

Home Email me Michael Rawdon (rawdon@leftfield.org) http://www.leftfield.org/~rawdon/